In this first article done by CBS news they say that we shouldn’t bail out the auto industry. It reports that Obama and the Democrats are psuhing for the bailout, but everyone else in the White House does not want to see this happen. The article also says that the Bush administration sees the $700 billion rescue as an emergency measure to save the financial sector on the grounds that finance is a utility and that no government would let the electric companies go under and leave the country without power. The article also talks about the amount of unemployed citizens sky rocketing upwards to 5 million along with mortage closures and buiness failures. It says that once you go and bailout this industry what other industry will be at the door next asking for money to be bailed out themsleves. Also, that by saving the auto industry it means saving them from bankruptcy and we saw through the airline companies that even the company is bankrupt it can still run smoothly. If the government was to bailout the auto industry it would burn up tens of billions of dollars and yet companies would still continue to fail. I don’t think this article was as persuasive as the other article. Yes it did provide facts, but the fact of people losing jobs and not being able to support their families isn’t right. As we did see though the government bailed out the auto industry and they still filed for bankruptcy so they basically wasted a lot of money on nothing, but from this article I don’t think that it was as persuasive as the other one and didn’t make me want to not bail out the industry.
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2008/11/14/opinion/main4604147.shtml
This second article is from Biztimes and it talks about the car industry needing to be bailed out. The article states that the car indurty is the backbone of American manufacturing. It also that the manufacturing is critical to the nations national defense which i dont realy understand how that can be. But the article goes on to say that we need to bailout the indutry to save 3 million family supporting jobs and a million retirees would lose their health care coverage. They use current examples to show the effects of the auto industry turning down jobs like in Janesville Wisconsin and it now has the highest unemployment rate in the country. It says that people aren,t buying cars because which is the second biggest purchase a family makes because credit is not available on reasonable terms. The companies have obviously been mismanaged as well. I think this article does a better job of persuading people to the side of we needing to bail out the auto industry. Obviously this article is in favor for it because of the jobs it will save and that is what people care about expecially those who work for the big 3 auto companies. The use of facts I think is what helps this article to successfully steer people towards the side of bailing out the industry. When you throw around a lot of those big numbers it makes the article solid and facts are crucial to persuading people one way or the other unless you are a smooth talker. I definitely think this article is more persuasive then the CBS news article.Even though we should have not bailed out the industry and made them file for bankruptcy after the fact this article persuaded me that we should.
http://www.biztimes.com/blogs/milwaukee-biz-blog/2008/11/20/we-must-bail-out-our-auto-industry-with-strings-attached